sorry for jumping in on this thread so late on
i started a thread about the same thing way back in may this year about the same thing and it got over 35 pages long
i and so many other people were in the exact same boat as u lot
o2 did decide to give us all brand new phones after a long 2 months fight with them
to cut a long story short o2 didnt give any of us written notice that the T&C had changed to give us recon phones instead of brand new ones which were asking for as that was part of the policy
but now i believe they have written to you lot and changed the t&c so i think o2 can give you what they want
😞myself and everyone else on the thread i started cancelled the o2 insurance soon as the new phones arrived as o2 insurance is v expensive for a recon replacement , cheaper ins else where and new for old
good luck all hope u all get sorted i know exactly how u all feel
and here is my thread nd story of what happened (its very long)
http://forum.o2.co.uk/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=41663