The only 2 things I can think are,
1 your old watch is still registered on the system and is in conflict with the new one.
2 the new watch is faulty.
Start by asking O2 to check and remove your old one from your account.
Hi @jordmagx did you find out the issue behind your Apple Watch disconnecting?
→ COVID-19 support - Help and support from O2 during the lockdown
→ Access for You: Registration - Find out how to register for our Access for You service.
→ Just joined the community or thinking of registering? Check out this handy starter guide!
→ Have a query about your account? login to My O2 for help
If you'd like to take part, why not register?